Too many in the Church today have embraced the idea that God has cast off Israel and replaced her with the Church. This belief, known as Replacement Theology or Supersessionism, is not only theologically flawed; it strikes at the character of God Himself.
From Genesis to Revelation, the God of Scripture is a covenant-keeping God. In Genesis 17, He calls His promise to Abraham and his descendants everlasting. Not conditional. Not symbolic. Everlasting. The land, the nation, and the blessing were never contingent on Israel’s perfection but on God's faithfulness.
To deny Israel’s ongoing role in redemptive history is to deny the permanence of God’s word. Romans 11 is Paul’s definitive rejection of Replacement Theology. He calls Israel “beloved for the sake of their forefathers,” and declares that “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable.” The Gentiles have been grafted in to the olive tree of God's covenant, not as a replacement but as participants in the story of redemption that began with Abraham.
Scripture gives us a clear mandate to pray for Israel. Psalm 122:6 says, “Pray for the peace of Jerusalem.” This isn’t a political suggestion, t’s a spiritual responsibility rooted in God’s covenant and His unfolding redemptive plan. At the same time, our hearts should reflect God’s love for all nations. We are called to intercede for every people, every tribe, and every land. Praying for Israel does not mean ignoring others; it means aligning with God’s priorities while carrying His heart for the whole world.
Common Arguments
“Therefore I tell you, the kingdom of God will be taken away from you and given to a people producing its fruits.” Matthew 21:43
- Used to argue: God has rejected Israel and given the kingdom to the Gentile Church.
- Contextual response: Jesus is warning the corrupt religious leaders of His day, not issuing a blanket rejection of Israel. The remnant of Israel remains central to God's plan (see Romans 11).
“There is neither Jew nor Greek... for you are all one in Christ Jesus. And if you are Christ’s, then you are Abraham’s offspring, heirs according to promise.” Galatians 3:28–29
- Used to argue: Ethnic distinctions, including Jewish identity, are now irrelevant.
- Contextual response: Paul is emphasizing unity in salvation, not erasing God's covenantal distinctions or promises to Israel.
“For no one is a Jew who is merely one outwardly... but a Jew is one inwardly...” Romans 2:28–29
- Used to argue: The true Israel is now spiritual believers, not ethnic Jews.
- Contextual response: Paul is critiquing hypocrisy, not redefining Israel. Romans 9–11 makes clear that physical Israel still plays a key role in God’s plan.
“In speaking of a new covenant, he makes the first one obsolete.” Hebrews 8:13
- Used to argue: The Mosaic covenant is obsolete, so Israel’s role is too.
- Contextual response: The Mosaic covenant was always temporary. But God’s promises to Abraham and David are everlasting (Genesis 17, 2 Samuel 7). The New Covenant is given to “the house of Israel and Judah” (Jeremiah 31:31).
“You are a chosen race, a royal priesthood... Once you were not a people, but now you are God’s people.” 1 Peter 2:9–10
- Used to argue: These titles for Israel now belong solely to the Church.
- Contextual response: Gentile believers are included in Israel’s blessings, but not as a replacement; rather, as a grafted-in people (Romans 11:17–24).
Zionism
Biblical Zionism is not the same as political Zionism. Biblical Zionism is the recognition that God is fulfilling His covenant promises to Israel as revealed in Scripture. Isaiah 66:8 asks, “Can a nation be born in a day?” This question was answered in history by the miraculous re-establishment of Israel in 1948. This event is not merely a political development or historical coincidence; it is a providential act of God.
Critics often conflate this with political Zionism, pointing to the secularism or policy failures of the modern Israeli state. But God has never required flawless instruments to accomplish His will. He used Cyrus to restore Jerusalem (Isa. 45), Nebuchadnezzar to discipline Judah, and even pagan empires to shape redemptive history. Political Zionism is a modern nationalist movement, often driven by geopolitical interests. Biblical Zionism, by contrast, is theological. It affirms God's faithfulness to His covenant with Abraham and His ongoing purpose for Israel. To reject Israel's place in God's plan is to misread eschatology, to confuse the distinction between Israel and the Church, and to strip Scripture of its covenantal depth. The Church does not replace Israel; it is grafted in, forming one new man in Christ (Eph. 2:15), as both Jew and Gentile await the fulfillment of God's promises.
Keeping Israel Accountable
To honor God’s covenant with Israel does not mean we excuse every action of the modern Israeli government. Just as we pray for our own leaders while calling them to righteousness, we can support the Jewish people and still speak with moral clarity.
The prophets of the Old Testament constantly called Israel to justice, mercy, and holiness. Micah 6:8 reminds us to do justice, love mercy, and walk humbly with our God. That applies in every nation, including Israel. When governments (any government) commit injustice, Christians are called to speak the truth in love. We grieve over innocent suffering. We advocate for peace rooted in truth, not propaganda. We pray for the salvation of both Jew and Arab. But we do not use Israel’s failures as a license to abandon her. We do not trade in slander, embrace conspiracy, or erase her prophetic role. The covenant remains, even when governments fall short.
The distinction between “chosen” and “favorite” is critical when understanding Israel’s role in God’s redemptive plan. Israel is not God’s favorite nation, as if He loves them more than others, but they are His chosen people, selected for a specific purpose: to reveal His character, uphold His covenants, and ultimately bring forth the Messiah. Being chosen is not a status of superiority or favoritism. Deuteronomy 7:7–8 makes this clear: God did not choose Israel because they were numerous or impressive, but because of His love and His promise. His election of Israel reflects His faithfulness, not their favoritism.
Conspiracy Theory
Throughout history, Satan has sought to destroy God’s chosen people, first through swords and exile, now through slander and suspicion. What once hid in the shadows of medieval Europe now circulates online, in casual conversation, and even in some corners of the Church. The form has changed. The spirit has not.
In the 14th century, as the Black Death ravaged Europe, Jewish communities were scapegoated and falsely accused of poisoning wells. Thousands were massacred. During economic downturns in medieval societies, Jews were cast as greedy manipulators, blamed for societal ills they neither caused nor benefited from. In Nazi Germany, these same patterns resurfaced under a new banner (race science and nationalism) leading to the industrial-scale murder of six million Jews.
Tragically, even the Church was not immune. Martin Luther, though used mightily by God in the Reformation, wrote harsh anti-Jewish polemics later in life. Centuries later, the Nazis reprinted his words as justification for their genocide. This should sober every Christian: theological error, when joined to political power and national pride, can become monstrous.
Today, the same lies have adapted to modern anxieties. Some claim Jews control global finance, media, or governments. Others blame Israel for every conflict in the Middle East, applying standards they wouldn’t apply to any other nation. These accusations are not rooted in reason, evidence, or justice; they are rooted in ancient hatred dressed in the language of “truth-seeking” and “geopolitical analysis.”
Let us be clear: to say “the Jews run the world” is not discernment, it is demonic. These conspiracies are not just false; they are spiritually destructive. They reflect the same spirit that fueled pogroms, ghettos, and death camps. They grieve the heart of God who called Abraham, revealed His Word through the prophets of Israel, and brought forth the Messiah from the tribe of Judah.
As followers of Christ, we are called to reject “irreverent babble and contradictions of what is falsely called knowledge” (1 Tim. 6:20). To trade in these accusations is to bear false witness, violate God’s law, and perpetuate cycles of hatred. Our call is not to spread suspicion, but to bless Israel (Gen. 12:3), pray for the peace of Jerusalem (Ps. 122:6), and walk in truth and love.
We do not excuse injustice, but neither do we slander God’s covenant people. In every age, antisemitism has been a spiritual test, revealing whether the Church will stand with God's purposes or succumb to the spirit of the age. Let us choose rightly. Let us expose the lies, renounce the conspiracies, and proclaim the enduring covenant of our faithful God.
So let us be cautious. To oppose Israel categorically or to dismiss her significance is not simply a political opinion. It is a theological statement. And if that statement contradicts the faithfulness of God, the continuity of Scripture, and the heart of Paul’s gospel, then it must be rejected.
God is not finished with Israel. His covenant stands. His purposes prevail. And His Church, if she is wise, will not boast against the root but humbly honor the story we have been grafted into.
.svg)
